↑
  • Capsule Wardrobes
  • Gift Ideas
  • Party Planning
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Everyday Savvy

Style, Gifts, Parties

  • Capsule Wardrobes
  • Gift Ideas
  • Party Planning
You are here: Home / Life Hacks / Best Non-Candy Easter Egg Fillers

Best Non-Candy Easter Egg Fillers

February 21, 2025 By Heidi Leave a Comment
This post may contain affiliate links that help support this site at no additional cost to you. Please read my disclosure page for more info.

88 shares

Filling and hunting Easter Eggs is such a fun activity for kids. Hunting for eggs is one of their most favorite memories as little kids.  It can be a challenge to find some of the Best Non-Candy Egg Fillers for kids. We found some cool small fillers for kids.   

Most often, the amount of sugar can be overwhelming on holidays and you may be looking for small prizes and little fun treats to fill those Easter Eggs, instead of candy. Easter basket fillers have to be small or flexible to fit inside of plastic eggs too. Whether you do Easter Egg Hunts at home, at church and at school, we found a variety of cool things that will take your Easter Egg Hunt to the next level. We found some of the Best Non-Candy Easter Egg Fillers that you can order easily, for your Easter Egg Hunt. 

Best Non-Candy Easter Egg Fillers

This year, forget the sugar overload on Easter. Your kids won’t be disappointed that their Easter Eggs aren’t filled with candy this year. Their disappointment will turn into excitement, when they find cool little prizea inside their eggs. We found neat things like shoe charms, woven bracelets and even faith-based fillers. If you are looking for the Best Non-Candy Easter Egg Fillers, we found some fun little things that your kids will love. Whether you are doing a home egg hunt with family or a school egg hunt, we found some adorable little prizes, to surprise kids of all ages.

If you are looking for fillers for Easter Baskets, we have lots of ideas, all organized by age. Be sure to check all our Easter Basket ideas for kids, tweens, teens and adults.

Best Non-Candy Easter Egg Fillers for Kids

We found some cool and unique Non-Candy Easter Egg Fillers for kids of all ages. Some of these items fit in the standard size plastic Easter egg and some of these fillers fit in the larger plastic Easter eggs.

Photo Credit: Amazon

Animal Fidget Pop with Keychain

You will need the larger plastic Easter eggs for these adorable Animal Fidget Pop Keychains, but they are super cute and affordable for Easter Egg fillers. Kids can push in the fidget buttons and squeeze the animals to release the buttons. Each animal includes a ball chain so you can attach them to a backpack or keychain.

Photo Credit: Amazon

Balloon Eraser Animals

These adorable Balloon Animal Erasers would make a fun and affordable Easter egg filler. They come in 1.5-3 inches in size and in 6 different colors.

Photo Credit: Amazon

Crayola Globbles Squish Toys - 16 count

These high-reviewed, Globbles from Crayola are fun, sticky squishballs that won't leave a mess! Your kids can squish them, stretch them and throw them. You can wash them to revive their stickiness too! This pack includes 16 Globbles in a variety fo colors.

Photo Credit: Amazon

Building Block Keychain

These Lego-inspired building block keychains are fun for your young builders. They are small-sized and perfect for fitting in Easter Eggs.

Photo Credit: Amazon

Food Pencil Erasers

These super cool Food Erasers will be a hit with your kids. Our local independent toy store sells these at the counter and these make a great Easter Egg stuffer. I love the cute ice cream, pizza, sushi and more. Your kids can use them at school or they make fun pretend food for army guys or dolls.

Photo Credit: Amazon

Mini Animal Building Block Sets - 24 Packs

These adorable Mini Animal Building Block Sets are perfect non-candy Easter egg stuffers. Each mini set is individually wrapped and includes building blocks and instructions. Each set can be built in three different ways too! This box includes 24 packs of block sets.

Photo Credit: Amazon

Blackout Dice - Bulk Pack

A pair of these cool Black Out Dice would be a exciting little treat. Your kids can use them to play games, update the dice in their board games and more. They will love the black dice with neon number accents. You could even mix and match the pairs for a fun look! This pack includes 50 dice or 24 pairs!

Photo Credit: Amazon

Kawaii Charms Keychains for Phones/Backpacks/Zippers

These little detailed Kawaii Charm keychains are a fun little treat for older kids. They can be used for keychains, backpack zipper pulls or for cell phones charms.

Photo Credit: Amazon

Food Shoe Charms

You can find shoe charms in just about any theme. These adorable Kawaii-style Food Shoe Charms make useful little treats. Most kids have a pair of crocs or similar clog-style shoes and it is fun to personalize them with these charms.

Photo Credit: Amazon

Silicone Suction Bath Toys - 16 Count

These adorable Silicone Suction Bath Toys are perfect for younger kids. Each pack contains 16 cute animals that can suction to the bath tub, windows, the mirror and more.

Photo Credit: Amazon

Pop Fidget Bracelets

You have seen fun fidget pops everywhere, but now you can find these fun-colored Pop Fidget Bracelets. They are a great size to fit in your kids easter eggs, plus they are made of silicone, making them easy to stuff in the eggs.

Photo Credit: Amazon

Embroidered Iron-On or Sew-On Patches - 60 Pack

This adorable variety pack of Embroidered Iron-On or Sew-On Patches are too cute! They are perfect for decorating backpacks, pencil bags, clothing and more. They have glue on the backs so you can iron them on or sew them on, if the fabric is glue-resistant.

Photo Credit: Amazon

Mini Man Flexible Fridge Magnets

If you have a fridge that will hold magnets, a chalkboard or something else magnetic, these Flexible Mini Man Magnets are adorable. They are flexible and can pose on your fridge.

Photo Credit: Amazon

Kids Temporary Tattoos - 50 Pack

These adorable Kids Temporary Tattoo Packs come in a variety of themes. They are hypoallergenic and individually cut and are water and sweat-resistant. tattoos are made from safe and non-toxic materials, making them suitable for even the most sensitive skin.

Photo Credit: Amazon

Jelly LED Light-Up Rings

These fun, Jelly LED Light-Up Rings are fun to wear at night. They turn on and off and have a stretchy finger loop to fit a variety of sizes. This assorted pack comes with a variety of designs.

Photo Credit: Amazon

He Is Risen Easter Bracelet

If you are looking for faith-based Easter Egg Stuffers, these He is Risen Bracelets are great for kids of all ages and come in an assorted pack, with a variety of bright colors.

Photo Credit: Amazon

Galaxy Bouncy Balls

My kids used to love fidgeting with bouncy balls by bouncing them against the wall from their desk or tossing them to each other. These fun Galaxy Bouncy Balls are a fun take on the traditional bouncy ball.

Photo Credit: Etsy

Kids Buttons Bulk Pins

Your kids can accessorize their backpacks, bags or jean jackets with these cute Kids Button Flair Pins. They are small, perfect to fill those eggs. You can buy smaller quantities or save with larger quantities.

Photo Credit: Amazon

Woven Adjustable Friendship Bracelets

These Woven Adjustable Friendship Bracelets come in a variety of fun, bright colors that your kids will love. These bracelets fit wrists, sized from 3" to 10" inches, and each adjustable friendship bracelet includes a sliding knot closure, which can be lengthened or shortened according to your needs.

Photo Credit: Amazon

Kawaii Mochi Squishy Toys

Let's face it, kids love anything you can squish or stretch and these fun Kawaii Mochi Squishy Toys are a fun treat to fill their eggs. They come in a fun assortment and are a great fidgety little toy.

Photo Credit: Amazon

Jumpeez Spring Launchers

These cute Jumpeez Spring Launchers are fun toys for kids. Push them down and observe as they spring into the sky. The more force you apply, the higher they leap!

Photo Credit: Amazon

Stretchy Flying Ninjas

These fun Stretchy Flying Ninjas make a cute Easter Egg filler. Your kid can just stretch and they fly!

MORE EASTER BASKET IDEAS

Tween Boy Easter Basket Ideas  – many of these work for girls too!

 Easter Basket Ideas for Girls

 Easter Basket Ideas for Boys

 Arts and Crafts Easter basket ideas for kids

 Outdoor Toy Easter basket ideas

Easter Basket Ideas for Young Adults 

Subscribe to the News

Like what you see here? Get free printables and tips! Be sure to sign up to get the latest right in your inbox.

Success! Now check your email to confirm your subscription.

There was an error submitting your subscription. Please try again.

Don't forget to check your inbox! We respect your privacy. We will NEVER sell, rent or share your email address. Powered by Kit
88 shares

Leave a Comment Filed Under: Life Hacks, Party Games & Activities, Party Planning Tagged With: Easter, Egg hunt

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

The Best College Dorm Packing List for Girls

The Best College Dorm Checklist for Guys

Cool Dorm Room Bedding & Dorm Essentials

4th Of July Party Games

The Ultimate Dorm Decor Ideas

Footer

Explore More…

  • Cute Outfits
  • Gift Ideas
  • Party Planning
  • Capsule Wardrobe
  • Crafts
  • Recipes
  • Party Favors
  • Party Food

Browse Our Favorite Amazon Finds!

Check Them Out
  • Privacy
  • Getting Started
  • Contact Me
  • PR Info

Everyday Savvy is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

Copyright ©2025, Everyday Savvy. All Rights Reserved.
Design by Pixel Me Designs